Scorpio: cute or creepy?

I'm not sure your signs really have much to do with this matter. Once you love someone, i don't believe it ever truly goes away. If you both love eachother, go for it. It's a sweet, sweet thing to do, and a reminder to let him know that despite what he says, you're not going to forget about him and haven't. I feel like any guy in that situation would be touched and appreciate it. Who wouldn't love a gift from the one they love? Do it.